History Versus Legend
by Holly Jo on Aug.23, 2009, under All The Rest
On August 22, I-MPI investigated the Old School Baptist Church (Bear Creek Church) near Hannibal, MO. It’s a small stone church that was abandoned in the early 1900’s, fell into disrepair and became part of local legends of Marion County thanks to a wayward bobcat or panther according to the Department of Conservation.
Legend
The legend of the church has endured since the 60’s, growing with every telling. Originally, the story was that a woman was killed in the church’s tiny cemetery and her screams echoed across the area late at night. Residents would line the country road in hopes of hearing the unearthly sound. In 1982, the church was burned by an arsonist and the tale changed to a slave was burned to death in the structure by mob action. One final telling finds a boy falling in the cemetery, hitting his head on a headstone and dying, his scream as he fell being heard in the graveyard. So is the progress of legends.
History
The church was organized in 1821 by six local residents, meeting initially in the home of George and Anna Turner. It was the first constituted congregation north of Salt River. A log church was built in 1926, taking a reported 4 years to complete. It was one and a half stories with two balconies for the slaves that attended services. The present building was constructed in 1856 of stone and was in use until sometime after 1911. It’s unclear as yet when the church was no longer used for services. It was part of the Two River Association until that year.
This beautiful stone building was used by Norman Rockwell for an illustration of a church scene in the 1936 printing of “The Adventures of Tom Sawyer” by Mark Twain. It’s also the final resting place for Agness Flahtleroy, a slave owned by the family of Laura Hawkins, the model for Becky Thatcher.
The church and cemetery became the focal point of local legend in the 1960’s, when something sounding like a woman’s scream could be heard coming from the area. Hundreds flocked to the site with the hopes of hearing the scream. After the local authorities investigated the claims, it was determined by officials that a wild cat, i.e. bobcat or panther must have made the sounds, possibly in White Bear Caves nearby, causing it to echo through the area.
This incident drew attention to the site with some negative results. It became the target of thrill seekers, vandals and, regretfully, an arsonist. The church burned in 1982, leaving only the stone shell behind. Since then, the site has been cleaned and restoration is in process by the Cemetery Association.
Legend or History?
In all the research, there is no information on any deaths or trauma at this site. But, as with all history, the search goes on. We are currently reviewing our evidence and will post updates and report later.
Personally, we found this beautiful church and it’s cemetery quiet and peaceful. The crickets chirped and birds sang around us in a symphony of nature. History practically came alive walking here among the stones. But is there paranormal evidence to back the legends? We will see, won’t we?
Remember, this is a historic site. We do not encourage anyone to trespass or defame the property in any way. Since there is such a multitude of legends attached to the church, it is watched carefully and fiercely protected by local law enforcement. Please respect the history.
October 15th, 2009 on 2:54 pm
Hey, I read a lot of blogs on a daily basis and for the most part, people lack substance but, I just wanted to make a quick comment to say GREAT blog!…..I”ll be checking in on a regularly now….Keep up the good work!
- Marc Shaw
November 18th, 2009 on 6:52 am
oMG!! Great post!!
November 27th, 2009 on 1:09 am
yo… strange thoughts. p
December 5th, 2009 on 12:25 am
I enjoyed your blog.
February 13th, 2010 on 11:26 am
The occult has always interested me.There’s something about the things we don’t understand….Hopefully someday our science will catch up.
March 10th, 2010 on 12:49 pm
Do you have copy writer for so good articles? If so please give me contacts, because this really rocks!
March 13th, 2010 on 8:59 am
I didn’t understand the concluding part of your article, could you please explain it more?
March 20th, 2010 on 4:23 am
Hi – I want to say thanks for an interesting post about a subject I have had an interest in for a while now. I have been looking in and reading the posts avidly so just wanted to express my thanks for providing me with some very good reading material. I look forward to more, and taking a more proactive part in the discussions here, whilst picking up some knowledge too!!
March 29th, 2010 on 11:40 pm
That rss page on your site here is brilliant, you should tell people about it in your next post. I haven’t noted it a first, now I’m using it each morning to check on any updates. I’m on a really slow dial-up connection in Kentucky and it’s rather hindering to sit there and wait for such a long time ’til the page loads… but hey, I just found your rss page and added it to the Google Reader and there you are… I’m always up-to-date! Well buddy, keep up the good work and make that rss button a little bigger so that other people can enjoy that as well
April 7th, 2010 on 5:45 pm
Another Great blog post, I will be sure to save this post in my StumbleUpon account. Have a awesome evening.
May 13th, 2010 on 9:41 am
Just blowing some free time on Digg and I found your entry. Not normally what I prefer to learn about, but it was absolutely worth my time. Thanks.
May 30th, 2010 on 7:34 pm
Thank you for your compliment. These posts are written by our members, no copy writers here!
May 30th, 2010 on 7:49 pm
Legend gives this location the persona of “haunted church.” Tales of mayhem and madness are researched and found to be untrue historically. We find that this is the case with many sites that are the center of local legends. The tales grow over the years, becoming exponentially more interesting and scary. The history of the location does not match the legend. The conclusion of this blog is merely a comparison of the legend against the history showing the reader this phenomenon of human nature. We found no evidence in our investigation to support the local legend.